These two sunscreens have been fighting for the K-beauty SPF throne for two years running. The Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun Rice + Probiotics is the creamier, dewier of the two. SKIN1004 Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum SPF50+ is the lightweight watery-serum alternative. Both are labelled SPF50+ PA++++. Both use chemical (organic) filters only. Neither published ingredient list includes zinc oxide or titanium dioxide. The brands describe both as leaving little or no white cast, and both cost roughly the same. We compared labels, brand descriptions and commonly reported experiences; we did not wear-test them.
Which one suits you depends on your skin type and the finish you want.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun | SKIN1004 Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum SPF50+ |
|---|---|---|
| SPF/PA | SPF50+ PA++++ | SPF50+ PA++++ |
| Filter Type | Chemical (organic filters only) | Chemical (organic filters only) |
| Finish | Dewy, glowy | Dewy watery serum (listing) |
| Key Skincare Ingredient | Rice bran + probiotics | Centella asiatica + hyaluronic acid |
| White Cast | Little to none reported (brand claim and common user reports) | Little to none reported (brand claim and common user reports) |
| Size | 50ml | 50ml |
| Price Range | $24.95 | $23.84 |
| Best For | Dry, normal, dull skin | Oily, combo, acne-prone skin |
| Fragrance | Very mild herbal | Minimal |
Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun (Rice + Probiotics)
This post contains affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Shop Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun →
Texture and finish. Described by the brand and many reviewers as creamy but not heavy, with a dewy finish. Users with dry or normal skin often like the glow; users with oily skin commonly report it can look shiny by midday.
**Key ingredients. Rice bran extract and grain ferment filtrate (probiotics). It pairs sunscreen filters with skincare ingredients.
**UV protection. Uses modern chemical (organic) filters only, with no zinc oxide or titanium dioxide on the current ingredient list. Apply two finger-lengths for face and neck to reach the labeled protection.
**Under makeup. The dewy base works as a primer and gives foundation and cushion a hydrated base. Let it set for a few minutes before makeup to reduce pilling.
Reapplication. Here’s where it gets tricky. Reapplying over makeup adds visible shine. If you’re outdoors and reapplying every two hours, the dewiness compounds. Consider the Beauty of Joseon Aqua Sun for a lighter, less glowy option from the same line when you know you’ll reapply frequently. The original Relief Sun and Aqua-Fresh are compared in Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun vs Aqua-Fresh.
SKIN1004 Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum
Shop SKIN1004 Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum →
Texture and finish. The Mirai listing calls it a lightweight watery serum with a dewy finish, meant to apply without heaviness and with little or no white cast on most skin tones.
Key ingredients. The listing names Madagascar centella and multi-weight hyaluronic acid, alongside the UV filters.
UV protection. Uses chemical (organic) filters only, with no zinc oxide or titanium dioxide on the published ingredient list: diethylamino hydroxybenzoyl hexyl benzoate, ethylhexyl triazone, methylene bis-benzotriazolyl tetramethylbutylphenol (Tinosorb M), diethylhexyl butamido triazone. Labeled SPF50+ PA++++. Apply about two finger-lengths for the face to reach the labeled protection.
Under makeup. The listing says it works as a makeup base if you let it set for 60 to 90 seconds. It is described as layering cleanly; a heavy silicone primer on top can cause pilling.
Reapplication. The listing says to reapply every 2 to 3 hours in direct sun, and describes the watery serum as sitting cleanly over other products.
Head-to-Head by Category
UV Protection
Both are labeled SPF50+ PA++++. Both use chemical (organic) filters only, with no zinc oxide or titanium dioxide on the published ingredient lists. In daily use, applying enough matters more than the formula type.
Winner. Tie.
Finish and Appearance
The listings describe different textures, not a matte-versus-dewy test. Beauty of Joseon is the creamier rice sunscreen with a dewy finish. Water-Fit is the watery centella serum, and its listing also calls the finish dewy, with little or no white cast on most skin tones.
Winner. Subjective. BoJ if you want the rice-probiotic cream. Water-Fit if you want the centella and hyaluronic-acid serum.
Comfort Through the Day
SKIN1004 is described on the listing as a lightweight watery serum for combination and oily skin.
**BoJ’s dewy finish suits dry and normal skin. On oily skin or in humid weather, it can look shiny.
Winner. Skin1004.
Skincare Benefits
**BoJ has more skincare ingredients here, starting with the rice extract in its name. You’re getting a skincare step and a sunscreen in one.
SKIN1004’s listing names centella and hyaluronic acid; BoJ’s listing focuses on rice and probiotics.
**Winner. BoJ if you want rice and probiotics; Skin1004 if you want centella.
Value
Both come in 50ml tubes from budget brands. For current prices, check the product links. We covered both in our no-white-cast sunscreen roundup.
Winner. Tie.
For Deeper Skin Tones
Both listings describe lightweight formulas with little or no white cast. The Water-Fit listing adds that most skin tones see no cast, and that darker complexions may notice a very subtle cast at first that blends within a minute. BoJ’s listing describes a dewy finish.
**Winner. Depends on the finish you prefer.
If you want even more K-beauty sunscreen options, the Anua Heartleaf Silky Moisture Sunscreen offers another option that sits between these two in terms of finish.
Who Should Buy Which
Choose Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun if:
- You have dry, normal, or dull skin
- You want a dewy, glowy finish that doubles as a primer
- Brightening benefits matter to you
- You mostly wear sunscreen indoors or for commutes (less reapplication)
- You like the idea of skincare-meets-SPF
Choose SKIN1004 Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum if:
- You want the centella and hyaluronic-acid serum on the listing
- You want the lightweight watery texture the listing describes
- You have combination or oily skin, which the listing names for this texture
- You reapply sunscreen throughout the day
- You want the dewy finish the listing describes
**For the undecided: Keep both. BoJ for days you want the rice-probiotic cream. Water-Fit for days you want the lighter centella serum. For a full breakdown of SPF in your daily lineup, see our complete skincare routine guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do these sunscreens work for sensitive skin?
The Water-Fit listing pairs Madagascar centella with the filters and describes the serum as an option for sensitive skin. Both use chemical (organic) filters only, with no zinc oxide or titanium dioxide on the published ingredient lists. Someone who wants a mineral (zinc oxide) sunscreen should look elsewhere. Patch test either way. For more sensitive-skin SPF options, see our Korean sunscreens for acne-prone skin guide.
Can I use these under cushion foundations?
Yes. Both are described as workable under cushion foundations. BoJ’s dewy base adds luminosity. The Water-Fit listing says the serum works as a makeup base after it sets for 60 to 90 seconds.
How much should I apply?
Two finger-lengths (index and middle finger, from base to tip) for face and neck. Both products spread well enough that this amount covers adequately without looking heavy. Underapplication is the most common sunscreen mistake — more product matters more than which product you choose.
Do I need to double-cleanse to remove these?
A double cleanse works for both. An oil cleanser or cleansing balm removes either sunscreen.
Are these reef-safe?
These listings do not name oxybenzone or octinoxate. “Reef-safe” has no regulated definition. If reef safety is a priority, check each full ingredient list against your preferred standard.

